[{"data":1,"prerenderedAt":71},["ShallowReactive",2],{"q-house-107-1-civil-law-008":3},{"subject":4,"subjectSlug":5,"subjectKicker":6,"subjectShort":7,"subjectMcqNote":8,"question":9,"related":25,"sameNumber":50,"hasEssay":24},"民法概要","civil-law","民法概要 · Civil Law","民法","105–106 年 40 題(每題 1.25 分)、107 年起 25 題(每題 2 分)",{"id":10,"webId":11,"year":12,"session":13,"subject":4,"number":14,"stem":15,"options":16,"answer":21,"answerNote":22,"lawYear":12,"explanation":23,"freq":13,"indexable":24},"house-107-1-民法概要-008","house-107-1-civil-law-008",107,1,8,"甲乙丙丁共有 A 地，各有應有部分四分之一，甲乙丙三人未經丁之同意即將 A 地出賣給戊並為移轉登記，請問此物權移轉行為之效力為何？",{"A":17,"B":18,"C":19,"D":20},"有效","無效","未得共有人全體同意，係屬無權處分效力未定","債權行為效力未定，物權移轉行為亦受其影響而效力未定","A",null,"本題考點：共有土地的處分，民法全體同意原則與土地法多數決特別規定的適用關係。\n【正解理由】依《民法》第 819 條第 2 項，共有物之處分、變更及設定負擔，應得共有人全體之同意，這是普通規定；但共有土地的處分，《土地法》另設有以多數決即可為之的特別規定，其門檻低於全體同意，特別規定應優先於普通規定適用。本件甲乙丙為四位共有人中之三人，應有部分合計四分之三，無論按人數或按應有部分計算均已逾半數，出賣並移轉登記於戊的物權行為即屬有效，不因欠缺丁的同意而受影響，故選 A。\n【逐項排除】\n(A) 同意處分者已達《土地法》就共有土地所定的多數門檻，物權移轉行為有效，為本題答案。\n(B) 無效指的是違反強制或禁止規定等情形，本件既依《土地法》關於共有土地處分的特別規定為之，又已依《民法》第 758 條第 1 項完成登記，不生無效問題。\n(C) 未得全體同意即屬無權處分而效力未定，是《民法》第 819 條第 2 項配合《民法》第 118 條第 1 項所得的結論，於共有土地因有特別規定而不適用。\n(D) 出賣他人之物的債權行為本身有效，出賣人只是承擔給付義務；物權行為的效力另依其處分權與登記判斷，兩者分別認定，不會連動。\n【記憶點】共有土地看土地法的多數決，共有動產才回到民法的全體同意。",true,[26,30,34,38,42,46],{"webId":27,"stem":28,"number":29,"year":12,"session":13},"house-107-1-civil-law-007","下列有關農育權之敘述，何者錯誤？",7,{"webId":31,"stem":32,"number":33,"year":12,"session":13},"house-107-1-civil-law-009","下列有關夫妻分別財產制之規定，下列何者錯誤？",9,{"webId":35,"stem":36,"number":37,"year":12,"session":13},"house-107-1-civil-law-006","債務人甲所有之抵押物上，設有擔保乙 200 萬元債權之第一次序抵押權、丙 120 萬元債權之第二次序抵押權及丁 50 萬元債權之第三次序抵押權。抵押物拍賣所得價金為 300 萬元。乙將其第一次序之優先受償利益拋棄予丁，則應如何分配拍賣所得之金額？",6,{"webId":39,"stem":40,"number":41,"year":12,"session":13},"house-107-1-civil-law-010","下列有關夫妻法定財產制之敘述，下列何者正確？",10,{"webId":43,"stem":44,"number":45,"year":12,"session":13},"house-107-1-civil-law-005","甲向乙貸款新臺幣 500 萬元，以其所有之 A 地及其上之 B 屋設定抵押權給乙作擔保。試問下列何者非屬抵押權效力所及？",5,{"webId":47,"stem":48,"number":49,"year":12,"session":13},"house-107-1-civil-law-011","16 歲之甲於騎車上學時，與正在送貨之某公司送貨員乙（30 歲）擦撞，並導致路人丙受傷。若甲與乙均為違規駕駛，下列敘述何者正確？",11,[51,55,59,63,67],{"webId":52,"year":53,"stem":54,"number":14},"house-114-1-civil-law-008",114,"關於無因管理之制度，下列何者非屬我國民法相關規範之內容？",{"webId":56,"year":57,"stem":58,"number":14},"house-113-1-civil-law-008",113,"甲將其所有之 A 屋出租於乙，乙未經甲之同意，將 A 屋全部轉租於丙。下列敘述，何者正確？",{"webId":60,"year":61,"stem":62,"number":14},"house-112-1-civil-law-008",112,"下列何種契約性質上屬於要物契約？",{"webId":64,"year":65,"stem":66,"number":14},"house-111-1-civil-law-008",111,"有關現行民法代理制度之介紹，下列何者錯誤？",{"webId":68,"year":69,"stem":70,"number":14},"house-110-1-civil-law-008",110,"關於抵押權所擔保而得優先受償之利息，以於抵押權人實行抵押權聲請強制執行前幾年內發生及於強制執行程序中發生者為限？",1786689127740]